Thursday, January 10, 2013

A Timely and Judicious Call to Civility from the President of the University of Notre Dame


Several decades ago, my predecessor as the president of the University of Notre Dame, the Rev. Theodore M. Hesburgh, was presented with a dilemma. A Jewish student, after repeated hazing by some kids in his dorm, had left campus and gone home. After thinking it over, Father Hesburgh summoned the perpetrators. "Pack your bags," he told them. "Go find your friend. Either you persuade him to come back to Notre Dame, or you don't come back."
The approach worked for everyone concerned, and it may offer an idea for easing the incivility that marks much public discourse and leads to political stalemate. We need to try harder to persuade one another—to try to get people to change their minds.
There isn't nearly enough persuasion going on in America today, and there was too little, in the view of many citizens, in the past presidential campaign. A postelection Pew poll found that the 2012 campaign was a "frustrating experience" for many voters: 68% said there was more "negative campaigning and mudslinging," with less discussion of issues.
The recent fiscal-cliff negotiations might have ended in a budget deal, but the rhetoric during the wrangling was hardly of the persuasive variety.
That is likely because much of the election campaigning and much of the budget discussion wasn't designed to change anyone's mind, but instead to encourage people to believe more deeply what they already believed—not about policies, for the most part, but about the villainy of the other side.
In the presidential campaign, the negative ads and speeches may have been unfortunately effective. A Washington Post-ABC News poll from last summer reported that 70% of Republicans saw President Obama in a strongly unfavorable light, and 57% of Democrats had a very unfavorable view of Gov. Romney. These were historically very high numbers for two presidential contenders.
As a country, we seem to have become the factions James Madison warned against in 1787, when he wrote: "A zeal for different opinions concerning religion, concerning government, and many other points . . . have, in turn, divided mankind into parties, inflamed them with mutual animosity, and rendered them much more disposed to vex and oppress each other than to cooperate for their common good." A more earnest effort to persuade one another could help remedy many of the problems we face.
I confess that I am deeply biased. I am a university president with a strong belief in the power and importance of a liberal arts education. I believe that deep and candid dialogue, marked by many acts of courtesy and gestures of respect, is a discipline that brings us nearer the truth about ourselves, about our opponents, about human nature, and about the subject under debate. To shut down this source of wisdom because we are too angry to hear the other side is a tragic setback in our quest for knowledge and our hope for a healthy society.
What if, instead of dealing with opponents by demonizing them and distorting their views, we were to take some steps to persuade them? I don't mean to suggest that one could persuade a stalwart partisan to switch parties, but perhaps one could persuade another that a particular policy or a position is "not as bad as you think."
If I am trying to persuade others, I first have to understand their position, which means I have to listen to them. I have to appeal to their values, which means I have to show them respect. I have to find the best arguments for my position, which means I have to think about my values in the context of their concerns. I have to answer their objections, which means I have to work honestly with their ideas. I have to ask them to listen to me, which means I can't insult them.
If we earnestly try to persuade, civility takes care of itself.
Civility is sometimes derided in the modern world, where bluntness and even coarseness have somehow come to be celebrated in many quarters. But civility is not a minor virtue. It is not an attempt to impose someone's notion of courtesy, and it is certainly not an attempt to suppress speech. Civility is what allows speech to be heard. It is an appeal to citizens never to express or incite hatred, which is more dangerous to the country than any external enemy.
A more sincere effort to persuade one another would remind us why the Founders believed this country could improve on history: We were the first society in many centuries with the chance to use free speech and sound argument to debate our way toward a better future.
That path is still open, and as promising as ever.
Father Jenkins is president of the University of Notre Dame. His book "Conviction: The Power and Peril of Our Passionate Beliefs" will be published by Random House later this year.

A version of this article appeared January 9, 2013, on page A11 in the U.S. edition of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Persuasion as the Cure for Incivility.

75 comments:

Anonymous said...


I love reading articles like this. Articles like this give me writing inspiration not only for writing articles but also for work in general.

Carolyn Klos said...

Reading articles like this one improves intellectual level. Also, I recommend reading such articles as https://www.iiste.org/tag/domyessay/, I like this article a lot)

THE HEALTH CONNECTION said...

Pharmamedsstore is an online Pharmacy that connects you with some of the most trusted pharmacies that deal with
storing generic medications around the globe.
https://www.pharmamedsstore.com/
modalert sun pharma
where to buy modafinil
modalert sun pharmaceuticals
cernos gel

Anonymous said...

Awesopme blog! Is your theme cusstom made
oor did you download itt from somewhere? A theme like
yours with a few simple adjustements would really make mmy blo shine.

Please let me know where you got your theme. Kudos

Anonymous said...

Hey! I know this iis smewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew
where I ould locate a capfcha plugin for my comment form?
I'm usng the same blog platform as yours and I'm having problems finding one?
Thanks a lot!

Anonymous said...

Buy Concerta Methylphenidate 54mg Online overnight without prescription
Buy Concerta Methylphenidate 54mg Online Best ADHD Medications
Where & How To Buy Concerta 54mg Safely Online in the World With No Risks
Cheap Quality Concerta Methylphenidate ADHD Pills For Sale Online
Purchase Concerta ( Methylphenidate ) 54 mg Online- USA, UK, DENMARK, CANADA, SPAIN
Buy Concerta Methylphenidate 54mg Online cheap quality concerta methylphenidate ADHD pills for sale online
Buy Concerta 54mg Online Safely

lucy said...

LSD
Order LSD
Order Liquid LSD
Buy Liquid LSD
Bu LSD sheets
Buy LSD blotter acid
Buy LSD
Buy LSD online
Liquid LSD for sale
Buy LSD Liquid
Purchase LSD Liquid
Buying LSD online
Where to buy Liquid LSD
DMT
Order DMT
Purchase DMT
Buy DMT
Buy 4-aco-DMT
Buy 5-meo-DMT
Buy DMT online
Buy DMT Vape pen
DMT for sale
Buy Ayahuasca
Order Ayahuasca
Ayahuasca for sale
Buy Ketamine Online
where to Buy Ketamine
Order Ketamine liquid
ketamine powder for sale
MDMA
Buy MDMA
Buy Ecstasy
Order Ecstasy
Buy MDMA Molly
where to buy MDMA Molly ecstasy
Buy Ecstasy online
ecstasy molly for sale
buying MDMA for sale
Order MDMA
Buy Magic mushrooms
Buy Magic mushrooms Online
OrderMagic mushrooms
Buy Shrooms online
Buy Mescaline
Buy Mescaline online
Mescaline for sale
Buy ibogaine
Buy Ibogaine online
Ibogaine for sale
Buy Kratom online
Kratom for sale

News ~ Findd Hindi said...

how many religions are there in india

buy medication overnite said...

online percocet 10/325mg best buy price
online roxicodone 15mg best buy price
online roxicodone 30mg best buy price

buy medication overnite said...

online methadone 10mg best buy price
online morphine 15mg best buy price
online morphine 30mg best buy price

buy medication overnite said...

online norco 10/325mg best buy price
online tramadol 50mg best buy price
online tramadol 100mg best buy price

buy medication overnite said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

buy opana 40mg with cash on delivery
buy opana 40mg with discount
buy opana 40mg with lower price

Anonymous said...

buy opana 40mg by immediately shipping
buy opana 40mg online urgent delivery
buy opana 40mg online with best discount

Anonymous said...

buy opana 40mg online with no rx
buy opana 40mg online available in california

Anonymous said...

butalbital order online with at best buy price
get ativan online in usa and canada
purchase paxil online on the web cod

Anonymous said...

purchase fioricet online with cod
cialis buy online at lower price

Adolf morgan said...

kop-rohypnol-online
kop-ritalin-online
kop-sodium-cyanide
kop-desoxyn-online
kop-percocet-online
kop-heroin-online
kop-oxycontin-online
kop-oxikodon-online
kop-opdivo-online

Adolf morgan said...

kop-morfinsulfat
kop-demerol-online
kop-dexedrine-online
kop-anavar-oxandrolone
kop-oramorph-online
kop-suboxone-pills
kop-stilnox-online
kop-vyvanse-online

Adolf morgan said...

Vårt apotek presenterar mer än 100 artiklar för behandling av acne, antibiotika, preventivmedel, erektil dysfunktion, hjärt -kärlsjukdomar, antidepressiva medel, smärtor, sömnhjälpmedel och andra. Vi har inte bara originalläkemedel utan också billiga mediciner från USA som är godkända av FDA och är exakta kopior av originalen. Vår uppgift är att ge varje medborgare mediciner av hög kvalitet oavsett inkomstnivå.

kop-adderall-online
kop-ambien-online
kop-botox-online
kop-dilaudid-8-mg
kop-fentanyl-online
kop-greenstone-xanax
kop-gron-xanax

Adolf morgan said...

order-dilaudid-8mg-online
order-morphine-sulfate-online
order-oxycodone-pills-30mg-online
best-subuxone-strips-online
order-yellow-xanax-online
oxycontin-pills-online
percocet-pills-5mg
roxycodone-pills-30mg-online
suboxone-pills-8mg

Kreb said...



SearchOnlineMeds is an amazing blog to acquire all the knowledge about medicines and its uses.
order hydrocodone
order adderall
order oxycodone pain killer
order opana

buy vyvanse online said...

zytiga abiraterone
dabrafenib tafinlar
trametinib mekinist
ghb pillen
ghb flussiges ecstasy
gbl pulver
Ephedrin
somatropin
Medizin
CMVEE Valganciclovir

Olivia Lane said...

Thanks for this post. Buy modafinil online at the best price from a trusted pharmacy. Modafinil is used to treat narcolepsy and other sleeping disorders. get effective offers on other pills in our pharmacy. http://www.pillsmart.co/modafinil/

Olivia Lane said...

Thanks for this blog, it was a very informative blog for me. Pillsmart is our trusted pharmacy that can provide medicine to needy one who is suffering from extreme sleepiness and narcolepsy. buy Armodafinil at the best cost. armodafinil assists with treating narcolepsy and other dozing messes.

acquista-opana-online said...

comprar-green-xanax
comprar-hidrocodona-en-linea
comprar-metadona-10m
comprar-morfina-15mg
comprar-opana-en-linea
comprar-oxicodona-en-linea

thetravelshots said...

Amazing feed
loved the article
I was searching for the type of high-quality content…

Olivia Lane said...

I really like this informative blog. It's helpful for me.Buy Generic Propecia to improve male pattern baldness.

jones said...


comprar oxycontin en linea
comprar percocet en linea
comprar polvo nembutal
comprar psilocybe cubensis b
comprar rubifen espana
comprar soma en linea
comprar suboxone en linea
comprar subutex en linea
comprar ultram en linea

Olivia Lane said...

Thanks for this amazing post. Buy Celebrex Online from a trusted pharmacy to relieve osteoarthritis symptoms and relieve the symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis in adults. It is also used to manage acute pain in adults.

Anonymous said...

You have performed a great job on this article buy 710 kingpen vape carts online europe
I really appreciate your website

Modafinila said...

Thank you for your wonderful blog.
buy arcalion online  to improve physical and mental strength.

Navi Mumbai News 24 said...

Thank you for your great article
Wholesale Knit Fabric Suppliers at very low price .

roulettesitetop said...

Readers are always admiring informational blogs, and this is truly one of them. You did a great job. 토토사이트

Unknown said...

These are truly great ideas in about blogging. You have touched some good things here.
Any way keep up wrinting. Buy Generic Klonopin Clonazepam Rivotril 2mg Online USA

roulettesitetop said...

I think you’ll proceed posting and updating frequently. Looking forward to your subsequent one. Feel free to visit my website; 룰렛사이트탑

nicky said...


Awesome.. geweldig...grymt bra...fantastisch

Kopa Korkort


Rijbewijs Kopen


fuhrerschein kaufen


comprare patente


acheter permis de conduire belgique


acheter permis de conduire en suisse


führerschein kaufen schweiz


rijbewijs Kopen België


nederlands-rijbewijs

gabby said...

acquista la tua patente italian frivers
Acquistapatentediguida
Servizi
Chi Siamo
DomandeFrequenti
comeottenereunapatentediguidasenzaesamediguida

Anonymous said...

I saw this amazing article and felt you should see it. Check it out and get new tips
Acquistapatentediguida
Servizi
Chi Siamo
DomandeFrequenti
comeottenereunapatentediguidasenzaesamediguida
contattaci

Nova Lucy said...

Purchase Vidalista 80 mg on the online within the event that the specialist endorses it for the treatment of erectile brokenness (ED) or slowness in men. Vidalista 80 mg has Tadalafil as its important dynamic fixing that is accessible in 80mg strength. This PDE60 medication is accessible in lighter doses and is kind of presumably the foremost supported meds for the treatment of erectile dysfunction in moderately aged men. Tadalafil Vidalista 80 mg is created by warrior Laboratories in Asian nation. Vidalista 80 works on condition that the patient is physically animated. It's a robust measurement and got to be taken on condition that it be counseled by the specialist. Yet, the specialist would possibly diminish the measure consistent with the physical or mental health of the patient.

Jamal said...

Saw an interesting article here go check it
patente b
patente-a
rinnovo patente
quiz patente
comprare patente

Anonymous said...


buy percocet

milasmith said...

Tadapox is a novel treatment that treats two different conditions in one pill. By utilizing tablets that contain two ingredients in the right amount, instead of two unique ingredients, you'll be able to solve the problems of ED or erectile dysfunction as well as premature ejaculation in one shot.

Cenforce 150 is a prescription drug that is prescribed to treat male erectile dysfunction. Taking it at least 30 minutes before sexual activity will increase the penis' blood circulation and help to improve male fertility. To ensure it is extremely effective and provides the most effective results.

OlexiiProkopa124 said...

From the time when you realize that getting an erection is becoming difficult, you have to act wisely. In many cases, difficulty in getting an erection is short-term and in such cases, you just have to give time to yourself. However, the problem of getting an erection becomes a regular issue of life then you have to do something. You cannot spend your whole life like this, as you have to fulfill the desires of your girlfriend or wife in the bed. Erection disorder is the basic reason for many divorces or breakups and you must not want to face these. Hence, starting using the pills, available for treating erection disorder like Cenforce 150.

Before you start using Cenforce 150 or any other pill for treating, you need to talk to your doctor. Cenforce pills are having Sildenafil Citrate, which is a generic compound used for treating erection disorder. However, you may across several side effects after using these pills when you don’t have a recommendation from a doctor. There are certain necessary tests that your doctor conducts for prescribing you a certain dose of Cenforce 150. You have to follow the instruction of your doctor for keeping this drug safe for your body. Even without showing a prescription, you cannot buy Cenforce 150 by using PayPal.

Cenforce 100

Cenforce 150

Cenforce 200

RSM Enterprises said...

Treat Sensual Capacity Issues in Men with Erex 100mg

Email : sales@rsmenterprises.in
Chat on WhatsApp with +91 92163 25377

Sildenafil 100mg
Erex 100mg Tablet
Buy Men Sexual Tablet

comprare patente originale said...

blog interessante
comprare la patente a napoli
comprare patente nautica

Olivia Lane said...

Armodafinil 150 mg is best medication for sleep disorders.

Mia Smith said...

Propecia is used for the treatment of male pattern hair loss on the vertex and the anterior mid-scalp area. Male pattern hair loss is a common condition in which men experience thinning of the hair on the scalp. Often, this results in a receding hairline and/or balding on the top of the head. Hair -Care - Buy Propecia Online

Damian Martin said...

Fildena 100 mg Get is a drug that is very well for its ability to relieve and provide an integrated health system free of sexual health illnesses such as erectile dysfunction.

Buy Fildena 100mg online


Jeromekilian said...

comprare patente b
dove e piu facile prendere la patente
patente b
patente-a
rinnovo patente
quiz patente
comprare patente

Aaron said...

nederlands-rijbewijs

comprarlicenciaautentica.com

comprare-patente

Jeromekilian said...

Buy Glock 19 Gen 5
Buy IWI Tavor ts12
Buy Remington V3 tac-13
Buy Mossberg 590 Shockwave
Buy Smith & Wesson MP15
Buy Remington Premier Accutip

Online Dispensary Canada said...

The specialist gives the patients a composed suggestion that it will mitigate the side effects of their condition. Patients then, at that point, have a few choices open to them relying upon which state's regulations they live under. Visit here Online Dispensary Canada

Olivia Lane said...

Thanks for sharing this blog with us. Buy Generic Propecia online to treat male pattern hair baldness.

hassem said...

xoloitzcuintle

how much does munchkin cats cost


munchkin kittens for sale near me

Olivia Lane said...

Thanks for sharing this blog with us. Buy Armodafinil Online for sleep disorders.

hassem said...

so beautiful 🤩 😻 😍 munchkin kittens for sale near me

hassem said...

so beautiful �� �� �� munchkin kittens for sale near me

Pdf Tool Online said...

This is called 'clump change. An individual can likewise choose a couple of pages with the end goal of transformation that is called 'fractional change'. The element of combining and parting can likewise make your undertakings sensible or convenient. Every one of these are remarkable and adaptable elements to change over the non-editable record into an editable one.
Rotate pdf online || merge pdf online || Split pdf online

hassem said...

Die haben die Möglichkeit dass ich die nächsten zwei Wochen comprare patente b vera 2021

eeleano23 said...

If you do decide to take hydroxychloroquine during pregnancy, there are some benefits as well as some risks. hydroxychloroquine-200-mg is also prescribed for the prevention and treatment of malaria.

PillSuppliers said...

great post
buy p super force to treat erectile dyfunction

eeleano23 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
eeleano23 said...

It also has some effects on its own as well, including reducing inflammation and limiting blood flow near the site of infection. If you have not had any symptoms or only mild symptoms, your doctor might recommend just taking buy ivermectin online instead.
visit us buy ivermectin online

Anonymous said...

What is the purpose of ivermectol 12 mg?
Picture of ivermectin 12 mg
What does it serve? The drug New ivermectin 12mg is a member of the ectoparasiticides drug class. It aids in the treatment of numerous parasite infections, such as strongyloidiasis, which causes certain types of diarrhea, head lice, scabies, river blindness, and other worm infections.for more detail (ivermectin 12mg)

toress said...

What is the purpose of ivermectol 12 mg?
Picture of ivermectin 12 mg
What does it serve? The drug New Ivermectol 12 Tablet(iverjohn!
) is a member of the ectoparasiticides drug class. It aids in the treatment of numerous parasite infections, such as strongyloidiasis, which causes certain types of diarrhoea, head lice, scabies, river blindness, and other worm infections.

walkersmith said...

Sildenafil USP 100 mg and Dapoxetine HCL 60 mg are contained in Super P-Force Oral Jelly. Sildenafil is a PDE5 inhibitor and the first erectile dysfunction drug. It is best known under the first brand name Super P-force. Sildenafil and Dapoxetine are also contained in Super P-Force Oral Jelly. This prescription is ingested into your circulation quickly, and you will most likely feel the effects within 30 minutes. Super P Force oral jelly liquefies incredibly quickly and is digested by the body's proteins roughly 30 minutes after consumption. Store P-Force jelly below 30°C. Keep away from children and pets. Signs of allergy such as rash, itching, or hives on the skin; shortness of breath, wheezing, or difficulty breathing; swelling of the face, lips, tongue, or other parts of the body

Mia Smith said...

Great Post.
Kamagra 100mg Oral Jelly Buy Online is an erectile brokenness medicine and a powerful treatment for men with erectile dysfunction.

ExpressHealth said...

acheter morphine 30mg en ligne
acheter norco ennligne
acheter hydrocodone en ligne
acheter subutex en ligne
acheter opana en ligne
acheter dilaudid en ligne
acheter levitra 20mg en ligne
acheter lortab en ligne
acheter codeine en ligne

Honey said...

"best salsa night in south delhi

best Bollywood Dance in south delhi

Salsa And Bachata Dance Classes

best digital marketing agency in greater noida

"

Honey said...

"Social Media Management Greater Noida
Facebook Advertising Greater Noida
Web Development Services Greater Noida
Affordable Website Design Greater Noida
Instagram Marketing Greater Noida
Brand Building Greater Noida
Performance Marketing Greater Noida
Website Design Greater Noida
"

Honey said...

"Social Media Management Greater Noida
Facebook Advertising Greater Noida
Web Development Services Greater Noida
Affordable Website Design Greater Noida
Instagram Marketing Greater Noida
Brand Building Greater Noida
Performance Marketing Greater Noida
Website Design Greater Noida
"

ckteam said...

"Local Digital Marketing Near Me
SEO Services Greater Noida
Local SEO Experts Greater Noida
On-Page SEO Greater Noida
Off-Page SEO Greater Noida
Technical SEO Audit Greater Noida
Social Media Marketing Services Greater Noida
Facebook Marketing Greater Noida
Instagram Marketing Agency Greater Noida
LinkedIn Marketing Services Greater Noida
Twitter Marketing Experts Greater Noida
PPC Services Greater Noida
Google Ads Expert Greater Noida
Facebook Ads Specialist Greater Noida
Paid Advertising Agency Greater Noida
Conversion Rate Optimization Greater Noida"

Honey said...

"Website Design Greater Noida
Web Design Services Greater Noida
Website Development Company Greater Noida
Affordable Website Design Greater Noida
Professional Website Designer Greater Noida
E-commerce Website Development Greater Noida
WordPress Website Design Greater Noida
Corporate Website Design Greater Noida
Responsive Website Design Greater Noida
Small Business Website Design Greater Noida
SEO-Friendly Website Design Greater Noida
Custom Website Design Greater Noida
Mobile-Friendly Website Development Greater Noida
Dynamic Website Design Greater Noida
Creative Website Design Greater Noida
Website Redesign Services Greater Noida
Website Maintenance Greater Noida
Website Hosting and Support Greater Noida
Website Security Services Greater Noida
Backup and Maintenance for Websites Greater Noida
Best Web Design Company Near Me Greater Noida
Website Design Agency Greater Noida
Web Developers Near Me Greater Noida
Local Website Designer Greater Noida
Freelance Web Designer Greater Noida
"

ckteam said...

"This is such a well-written post! In today’s digital landscape, a professionally designed website is essential for small and medium businesses to establish credibility and attract customers. For businesses in Greater Noida, opting for professional website design services can make a significant difference in their online success.

From creating visually appealing layouts to ensuring a mobile-friendly experience, a great website combines design with functionality. Companies like My Digital Dudes specialize in offering business website design in Greater Noida, ensuring clients get customized solutions tailored to their industry.

For those in retail, e-commerce website development is a game-changer, providing seamless online shopping experiences for customers. Meanwhile, real estate businesses can benefit from custom real estate website solutions designed to showcase listings and attract potential buyers effectively.

If anyone is looking to revamp their online presence, I highly recommend exploring the services offered by My Digital Dudes. Their expertise in website development and design ensures businesses can stand out in a crowded digital marketplace."